Agreed Value vs Market Value
Agreed Value vs Market Value: Which Costs You More at Claim Time?
When arranging insurance for vehicles, equipment, or certain business assets, you’re often given a choice between agreed value and market value cover. On the surface, this can seem like a minor technical detail, but the difference between the two can have a significant impact on what you actually receive if you ever need to make a claim.
Understanding how each option works, and where the risks lie, can help you make a more informed decision rather than defaulting to whichever option happens to be cheaper upfront.
What Is an Agreed Value Cover?
Agreed value cover means you and your insurer agree on a specific value for the insured item at the time the policy is arranged. If you make a successful claim for total loss, this is generally the amount you’ll receive, regardless of what the item might be worth on the open market at the time of the claim.
This approach offers a level of certainty, since you know in advance what you’d be entitled to. However, it also means the agreed figure needs to be set accurately and kept up to date, since an outdated valuation can leave you either overpaying for cover or underinsured relative to the item’s true replacement cost.
What Is Market Value Cover?
Market value cover, on the other hand, generally pays out based on what the item was worth immediately before the loss occurred, as assessed at the time of the claim. This figure isn’t fixed in advance and can be influenced by factors such as depreciation, market conditions, and the specific condition of the item.
Market value cover often comes with a lower premium, since the payout amount adjusts to reflect ongoing depreciation rather than a fixed, potentially higher figure. However, this also introduces more uncertainty, since you won’t know the exact payout amount until a claim is actually assessed.
Where the Real Cost Differences Show Up
At the time of a claim, not at the time of purchase
The cost difference between agreed value and market value cover often isn’t obvious until you’re actually making a claim. A lower premium on a market value policy can feel like a saving for years, only for the gap to become apparent if a total loss claim pays out significantly less than expected.
Depreciation and asset type
Assets that depreciate quickly are generally more affected by the difference between the two approaches, since market value cover will reflect that depreciation directly, while agreed value cover locks in a figure regardless of how the item’s market value has moved.
Specialised or modified items
For assets that have been customised, modified, or are otherwise harder to value using standard market comparisons, agreed value cover often provides more clarity and certainty, since the valuation process happens upfront rather than being contested at claim time.
The risk of outdated agreed values
Agreed value cover isn’t automatically the safer option in every situation. If an agreed value isn’t reviewed and updated over time, it can become misaligned with the item’s actual replacement cost, working against you in the opposite direction.
A Closer Look at How Each Option Plays Out in Practice
The agreed value scenario
Imagine a business insures a specialised piece of equipment under an agreed value policy, with the value set at the time the policy began. Years later, if that equipment is lost or destroyed, the payout is generally based on that original agreed figure, regardless of whether the equipment’s market value has since risen or fallen. If the figure was set accurately and reviewed over time, this provides genuine certainty. If it wasn’t reviewed, the business may find itself either overinsured, and paying more in premiums than necessary, or underinsured relative to what it would actually cost to replace the item today.
The market value scenario
Now imagine the same equipment insured under a market value policy instead. If a loss occurs, the payout is assessed at the time of the claim, based on factors such as age, condition, and prevailing market conditions for similar items. This can work well if the item hasn’t depreciated significantly, but for assets that lose value quickly, the payout may be considerably lower than what it would cost to replace the item with something equivalent.
Industries and Assets Where This Choice Matters Most
Vehicles and fleet assets
Vehicles are one of the most common areas where this choice comes up, given how significantly they can depreciate over just a few years. Businesses running a fleet of vehicles often need to weigh up the certainty of agreed value against the potentially lower premiums of market value cover, particularly across a larger number of assets.
Specialised or customised equipment
Equipment that has been modified, customised, or built for a specific purpose can be genuinely difficult to value using standard market comparisons. In these cases, agreed value cover often provides more clarity, since the valuation conversation happens upfront with input from the business owner, rather than being determined solely by a market assessment after a loss.
Machinery with a long operational life
Some machinery remains fully functional and valuable for many years beyond what standard depreciation schedules might suggest. In these cases, a market value assessment at claim time may undervalue the asset relative to its genuine ongoing usefulness to the business.
Practical Questions to Ask Before Choosing
How quickly does this asset typically depreciate?
Assets that lose value quickly generally see the biggest divergence between agreed and market value outcomes, making this question a useful starting point.
Has the asset been modified or customised?
The more unique or modified an asset is, the harder it becomes to assess fairly using standard market value methods, which often points toward agreed value as the more suitable option.
How committed am I to reviewing the value over time?
Agreed value cover only delivers its full benefit if the figure is kept accurate. If you’re confident you’ll revisit and update valuations regularly, agreed value can work well. If not, the risk of an outdated figure becomes more significant.
How does the premium difference compare across my full asset base?
For businesses insuring multiple assets, it’s worth comparing the cumulative premium difference between the two approaches across the full portfolio, rather than assessing each asset in isolation.
How to Decide Which Option Suits You
The right choice generally depends on the type of asset, how quickly it’s likely to depreciate, whether it’s been customised or modified, and how much certainty you value compared to a potentially lower premium. There isn’t a universally correct answer, it depends on weighing these factors against your specific situation.
This is exactly the kind of decision that benefits from a detailed conversation rather than simply choosing the cheaper premium at the point of purchase. MKW Insurance Brokers can help you weigh up which approach genuinely makes sense for your specific assets and circumstances.
FAQs
Is agreed value always the better option? Not necessarily. While it offers more certainty, it needs to be kept accurate and up to date to remain genuinely advantageous. For some assets and situations, market value cover may be perfectly appropriate.
How often should an agreed value be reviewed? It’s generally worth reviewing agreed values periodically, and particularly after any significant change to the asset, such as modifications, upgrades, or a notable shift in the broader market.
Does agreed value cover cost more than market value cover? This varies depending on the asset and insurer, but agreed value cover often comes with a different premium structure to reflect the certainty it provides. It’s worth comparing both options directly for your specific situation.
Can I switch between agreed value and market value cover later? In many cases, yes, though this generally needs to be arranged at renewal or through a policy variation, rather than mid-term. It’s worth discussing this with your broker if your circumstances or asset value change significantly.
What happens if I under-declare an agreed value to reduce my premium? This can significantly reduce what you receive at claim time, since the payout is generally based on the agreed figure regardless of the asset’s true replacement cost. It’s generally not a genuine cost-saving strategy, since it primarily shifts the risk onto you rather than reducing it.
Conclusion
The difference between agreed value and market value cover often isn’t obvious until claim time, which is exactly why it’s worth understanding upfront rather than assumed. The right choice depends on your specific assets and how much certainty matters to you.
To discuss which approach makes sense for your situation, get in touch with MKW Insurance Brokers.
